Volkswagen Polo vs Skoda Fabia vs Mazda 2 Genki – Which Car Should I Buy?

On the hunt for a small city car with safety and fuel efficiency? Here are a few cool choices

Volkswagen Polo vs Skoda Fabia vs Mazda 2 Genki – Which Car Should I Buy?
Gallery1

QUESTION – GLENN (April 14, 2017)

I’m looking for a car, prioritising fuel economy and safety. I drive daily around 20km and 140km a week, mostly around the city, so I’m looking for a small car. The best I could fine was a Volkswagen Polo 81TSI but I want to be sure.

BUDGET: $25,000

ANSWER – NATHAN PONCHARD:

There's a wealth of choice in the small-car market for less than $25K and you're correct in identifying the Volkswagen Polo 81TSI Comfortline DSG ($21,190 RRP, not including on-road costs) as one of the safest and most economical.

It's also roomy, gutsy, and confidence-inspiring to drive. However, you should be aware that the current shape has been on sale since 2010 and an all-new Polo generation will launch here in 2018.

Others we'd suggest looking at include the Polo's close cousin – the younger and funkier Skoda Fabia 81TSI – in two trim levels. The standard car is $19,490 RRP (with a range of cool, design-focused options available) while the more upmarket Monte Carlo is $23,490 RRP. You may be able to find a Fabia Monte Carlo for around $25K driveaway. There's also a Fabia wagon available (unique in this class).

As it stands, while there are fewer Skoda dealers around, they offer reasonably competitive fixed-price servicing, and given that the Fabia shares its entire mechanical and safety package with the Polo, you may like the fact that it's a little less common, a bit more cool, and can be individualised.

undefined

A third, extremely capable option is the Mazda 2 Genki ($22,690 RRP as an auto hatchback), which has just had a mild update, meaning you may be able to find the superseded model for a bit of a saving. The Mazda is a solid, fun, beautifully built hatch with the class-best reputation for reliability and resale value.

Finally, there's a terrific French pair – the Renault Clio Expression 120TCe ($21,500 RRP) and the Peugeot 208 Active ($22,490). The Clio is the more sophisticated of the pair, with a superb ride, lovely seats and funky design, while the 208 has a brilliant engine and transmission, and may be available with a discount seeing it's the least popular of the hatches mentioned here.

If you can find a 2016-build Peugeot 208 1.2 turbo auto for a discount, it could be a very persuasive buy.

I hope all this hasn't made you're choice more difficult! But these models mentioned here are the five best in the light-car class. And you can't really fail with any of them, especially the bulletproof Mazda 2.

 

How are you finding our new site design? Tell us in the comments below or send us your thoughts at feedback@whichcar.com.au.

 

Subscribe to Australian car magazines

Subscribe to any of our motoring magazines and save up to 49%


Subscribe

 

We recommend

NEWS

MG ZS EV
News

Victorian EV owners must submit odometer photos for tax or face losing rego

VicRoads still believes road user tax is necessary despite growing concerns surrounding implementation

5 hours ago
Jordan Mulach
Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.