­Korean marques again take the cake

1. Kia Rondo Si THERE’S more than one way to skin a people-mover, and that’s just on the podium. While our winner embodies old-school MPV values, others here are commercials doing passenger-car duty.

The Rondo has cropped up more than once at the pointy end of the Gold Star Awards, and it’s clear why. The $32,790 Korean bus is a cheap way of carting the family, and efficient as well, thanks to a 6.4L/100km turbo-diesel. Resale is reasonable and insurance is cheap-as. Then there’s Kia’s long service interval and five-year* warranty.

2. Hyundai iMax 2.5 CRDi SLX THE split between Hyundai’s huge eight-seater, a passenger version of its iLoad van, and third place was close. Size should make your decision clear.

3. Volkswagen Caddy Maxi Comfortline GOLF-DERIVED (up front, at least) Caddy, like iMax, has workhorse origins, but it drives like a hatch. Terrific 70 percent three-year retained value.

*STOP PRESS: Since pubication of this article, Kia has increased its warranty to seven years/unlimited kilometres

People-mover <$60kPurchase PriceComb. Fuel (L/100km)Fuel RON (min. rec.)3-year fuel costRedbook resale (%)3-year deprec.AAMI insurance prem.Service interval (months)Warranty (years)
Kia Rondo Si$32,7906.4D$386860$13,116$1044.91125
Hyundai iMax 2.5 CDRi SLX manual$41,4908.1D$489569$12,862$1085.49125
Volkswagen Caddy Maxi Comfortline$39,9905.8D$350570$11,997$1106.62123

Notable classmates: Citroen C4 Grand Picasso, Honda Odyssey VTi / Number of cars crunched: 10