2017 Holden Commodore SS V Redline vs 2008 BMW M3

Aussie grunt faces off against German muscle in a $60K dilemma

2017 Commodore SS V Redline vs 2008 BMW M3

Holden benchmarked BMW’s delightful E39 5 Series from a decade prior when developing the VE Commodore, and in the steering and suspension of 2006’s ‘billion-dollar baby’ it showed.

Meanwhile the VF Series II Commodore SS V Redline, as the pinnacle – excluding limited editions – of this final rear-drive sedan, coincidentally lines up with the now-decade-old BMW M3 E90 sedan and E92 coupe.

2008-BMW-M3.jpgFor driving enthusiasts with $55,000 to $65,000 to spend, this is a legitimate comparison. Both V8s are within 5kW of each other, the new Redline using an extra 170Nm to offset its 168kg-heavier kerb mass and match the M3’s 4.9-second 0-100km/h claim.

The BMW is now one-third of the price it was new, and on par with the Holden that is an equally cracking driver’s car.

30 Years of HSV: Coupe 4

The BMW E90/E92 was the first of the compact M cars to swap six cylinders for eight, and this delectable motor soared past its 8300rpm power peak with a strident, metallic howl.

Only 400Nm seems measly, but at 100Nm-per-litre it makes the pushrod LS3’s 570Nm look inefficient. The 6.2-litre is also slower to rev, with a soft sub-7000rpm cut-out.

2017-Commodore-SS-V-Redline.jpgEngine and cabin quality finesse is where the biggest differences between Australian and German lie. Both feature tuned two-stage ESC and mechanical limited-slip diffs; electrically actuated in the BMW that had inch-smaller 18-inch tyres – 19s optional.

The M3 had adaptive dampers matched only by the Commodore Motorsport Edition

Five ultimate BMW M3s part 5: M4 GTS

The generations that succeed both these two are also completely different in configuration and character – the boosted-six F80 M3 is as controversial for some as the next imported all-paw Commodore is. That will likely carve future-classic status into both the E90/E92 and VF Series II.

Here’s one from TradeUniqueCars.com.au

BMW M5 Unique Cars
WHILE examples with beyond 100,000km can be found for $40,000, this low-km, Oz-delivered coupe has a full service history – important when buying an M car. While manual is the go, the DCT was at least superbly tuned. View the ad here and be very, very tempted.



How are you finding our new site design? Tell us in the comments below or send us your thoughts at feedback@whichcar.com.au.


Subscribe to Motor magazine

Subscribe to MOTOR and save up to 49%
The world's most thrilling performance car magazine. Delivered to your door each month.



Daniel DeGasperi

We recommend


McLaren Artura

McLaren Artura lands Down Under

Hybrid supercar kicks off a new era for the British supercar maker

12 hours ago
Peter Anderson
Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.