All Aussie Showdown 2005: HSV Maloo R8 vs FPV Pursuit

Nothing’s more Aussie than utes in the Outback, but are they dumb trucks or two-door sportsters

All Aussie Showdown 2005 HSV Maloo R8 vs FPV Pursuit
Gallery10

I love my Blunstones, I love the Wallabies, I love Banjo Patterson’s work. And, man, I gotta tell you, I love utes. But as a consumer of utes (I’m on my third in eight years or so) I’ve got to wonder about the HSV Maloo R8 and FPV Pursuit.

This feature was originally published in MOTOR’s May 2005 issue

Based on the fact that I use my own trayback for everything from dragging a fishing boat around to hauling half a yard of topsoil, certain elements of either vehicle, particularly the Maloo, give me cause to question whether maybe the whole thing is getting too weird.

The HSV’s hard-tonneau (with a spoiler if ya don’t mind) for instance, limits what you can spontaneously scavenge from the tip, and those body kits won’t last long getting on and off building sites.

But then you look at the performance numbers, and you pull your head in, because two-seats-and-a-tray notwithstanding, these are potent sonsofbitches. The Pursuit’s 290kW is a pretty honest number and puts it closer to the HSV ute’s output than HSV itself might be comfortable with. On the dyno the FPV and HSV were within a fraction of a kilowatt of each other (226.6kW plays 226.4kW respectively).

On the other hand, on the dragstrip, the Henry just couldn’t keep up, and its 6.2secs 0-100 and 14.2 for the quarter-mile are both about two tenths behind the Maloo’s numbers. Not a bad effort, though, since it gives away more than half a litre.

All Aussie Showdown 2005 HSV Maloo R 8 Vs FPV Pursuit Performance Comparison Jpg
10

For the Maloo’s part, it’s a bit hard to see why it can’t get closer to the ClubSport’s 13.6 second quarter. I mean, they run the same boofy six-litre mill and six-speed ’box, yet the Maloo was nowhere near as quick as the Clubbie. Still, ute against ute, the HSV clearly gets away from the FPV in a straight line, in any gear. And that will count for a lot with many folks.

Away from the smooth hotmix of race-tracks and drag-strips, the Maloo pulls out an even bigger lead. While the Pursuit’s live, leaf-sprung rear axle feels pretty stone age when you start jumping it over lumps and craters in the backwoods bitumen, the Maloo’s independent set-up is far more likely to keep both rear treads firmly on the ground.

This is not something that takes any time to discover, either; it’s apparent from the moment you leave the town limits and crank things up to cruising altitude. The HSV’s advantage gets even bigger if you throw a few corners into the mix and that’s when the Pursuit’s front and rear ends stop talking to each other.

FPV Pursuit On Road Jpg
10

There’s a bit more to like about the Maloo’s engine-room, too, and while the Pursuit thrives on the sort of revs you don’t always feel like bothering with, the Gen IV stokes up early and just keeps on keeping on with a ripping top-end that seems like it’ll never stop.

The gear-shift is less happy, though, and the Henry claws a couple of points back in that department. In the final wash-up, not a single judge was moved to plump for the FPV, giving the Maloo five votes and daylight second, lack of track time notwithstanding (Maloo didn’t arrive in time).

The rider here is that things could be different if you actually use your 300kW utility for work as well as blatting around like a good ’un. See, as a work truck, the Ford has quite a bit more with which to recommend itself.

FPV Pursuit Front Jpg
10

The cabin is a good place to start and as well as a cleaner presentation, it’s also got the unqualified benefit of that stash-space behind the seats. The HSV can’t match that, nor can it compete with the clever, poly-urethane tray (it’s not a simple liner) that doesn’t scratch, can’t rust and even seems to heal itself if you slice it with something big and sharp.

The leaf-sprung bum will also be worth its weight in gold should you ever want to tow big, heavy stuff or cart a tray-load of gold bars. Of course, all those comments apply in a non-performance car sense. And this is MOTOR, so they don’t count quite so much as they might in Blue Singlet Monthly. Like we said, daylight second.

Fast Facts

All Aussie Showdown 2005 HSV Maloo R 8 Vs FPV Pursuit Fast Facts Jpg
10
  Pursuit Maloo R8
Engine 5.4L V8, DOHC 6.0L V8, OHV
Power 290kW @ 5500rpm 297kW @ 6000rpm
Torque 520Nm @ 4500rpm 530Nm @ 4400rpm
Weight 1870kg 1696kg
Fuel consumption 15.55L/100km 15.67L/100km
Price $60,285
(w/ $6000 optional Brembo)
$63,895

Dyno Results

All Aussie Showdown 2005 HSV Maloo R 8 Vs FPV Pursuit Power Graph Jpg
10

Both spot-on 226kW. Surprising given HSV claims 305kW DIN to FPV’s 290kW DIN. More strange is how Pursuit produces more power and torque across the range.

Drag Run

  Pursuit Maloo R8
0-10km/h 0.54sec 0.50sec
0-20km/h 1.00sec 0.92sec
0-30km/h 1.53sec 1.53sec
0-40km/h 2.09sec 1.98sec
0-50km/h 2.61sec 2.56sec
0-60km/h 3.07sec 3.03sec
0-70km/h 3.88sec 3.87sec
0-80km/h 4.58sec 4.62sec
0-90km/h 5.31sec 5.21sec
0-100km/h 6.22sec 6.02sec
0-110km/h 6.58sec 7.12sec
0-120km/h 7.99sec 8.43sec
0-400m 14.23sec @
163.2km/h
14.08sec @
166.8km/h

The Pursuit carries on with axle tramp if you try and launch with more than 2500rpm, still 6.22-seconds to 100km/h is sharp for a hay hauler. Maloo faster everywhere.

Track Results

  Falcon GT Clubsport
Lap Time 1min 57.59sec N/A
Top Speed 202km/h N/A

A 1:57.59 is sharp for a sedan let alone a ute, the Pursuit was surprisingly stuck-down and lots of fun.

Judges' Scores

HSV Maloo R 8 Judges Jpg
10

2005 FPV Pursuit

Judges JT DE DM PC LB
Performance/10 7 6 7 7 N/A
Dynamics/10 6 7 4 5 N/A
Driveability/10 6 6 6 4 N/A
Value/10 6 6 5 4 N/A
Total/40 25 25 22 20 N/A
GRAND TOTAL 92/160*

2005 HSV Maloo R8 - WINNER

Judges JT DE DM PC LB
Performance/10 9 6 8 9 N/A
Dynamics/10 7 8 6 6 N/A
Driveability/10 8 7 6 7 N/A
Value/10 7 7 5 5 N/A
Total/40 31 28 25 27 N/A
GRAND TOTAL 111/160*

* Lucky Bastard never drove the utes and therefore didn’t vote. Scores for utes are out of 160, not 200

 

How are you finding our new site design? Tell us in the comments below or send us your thoughts at feedback@whichcar.com.au.

 

Subscribe to Motor magazine

Subscribe to MOTOR and save up to 49%
The world's most thrilling performance car magazine. Delivered to your door each month.

Subscribe

 

David Morley
Journalist

We recommend

NEWS

David Coulthard Michael Schumacher flipping the bird
News

Opinion: The problem with villains in modern motorsport

No longer should a driver be immune from consequences for poor off-track behaviour

13 Jun 2021
Cameron Kirby
Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.