Ingolstadt replaces the sleek Audi S5 with a brawnier second generation car that improves the original in virtually every objective regard. Whether you find it prettier or more charismatic is a decision you’ll need to make.

WHAT IS IT

A 260kW all-wheel drive coupe with a huge breadth of talent, the latest Audi S5 will put its German rivals on notice. It’s a smart munition delivered straight to the crosshairs of its target market. The only people likely to be disappointed are those hoping it to be a cut-price BMW M4.

With some of the more tortuous bits of the Targa Tasmania route on hand, it’d be remiss of us not to treat the S5 to the most demanding test Australian roads can deliver. Audi also had the A5 coupe range to add some welcome perspective.

MAIN RIVALS

BMW 440i, Lexus RC 350, Mercedes-AMG C43 Coupe,

Audi is intimately acquainted with the customer base for the S5. It’s a clientele with an affinity for quality, design and a gnawing weakness for one-upmanship, for which this latest generation car unerringly hits the mark. Fast, composed, and beautifully built with a refreshingly discreet technology package, it’s a strong offering. Cutting $17k off the old car’s price to bring it into line with the Mercedes-AMG C43 coupe isn’t going to hurt the S5’s chances either.

PLUS: Pace, grip, composure, build, practicality, smart gadgetry MINUS: Sports diff needs to be standard, engine lacks aural fizz, off-key carbon-fibre fascia

Appreciating the Audi S5 requires but one thing and that is to accept that this 260kW all-wheel drive sports coupe doesn’t give its best when scruffed through a corner at ten-tenths.

Nobody who buys an S5 will drive it like this, yet legions of journalists have used its unconvincing impression of a Mitsubishi Lancer Evo as a means to pigeonhole the old car as something less than the real deal. The latest S5 demonstrates that Ingolstadt understands its target market and has clinically engineered a smart weapon to surgically part people from $105,800 of their hard-earned.

The styling is evolutionary, taking Walter de Silva’s magnum opus of lantern-jawed loveliness and chamfering a few curves into edges while implanting a few more Y chromosomes. It’s an in-house effort described by Audi designer Jakob Hirzel as “not exuberant.”

That engine certainly cranks out some impressive numbers. Delivering 500Nm from just 1370rpm via an eight-speed ZF automatic, it’ll punt the S5 through 100km/h in 4.7 seconds yet somehow there’s the unwelcome taint of responsibility about it. Audi will quote a fuel economy figure of 7.5L/100km – marginally better than our test figure of 16.9L/100km – but you’ll still struggle to resist boring your passenger witless about how the old 4.2-litre V8 was more fun.

A lot of work has clearly gone into polishing the all-new five-link suspension of the S5, with genuinely impressive ride quality even when the adaptive dampers are switched into their most aggressive Dynamic mode.

The optional $2950 Audi sport differential was fitted to all test cars and should be a standard fit item, delivering extra grip out of corners to the rear wheel best able to deploy it. The S5’s nominal torque split is 40:60 front/rear, and in the event of slip, up to 85 percent of drive can be directed forward or 70 percent aft.

Siting the Drive Select switch on the fascia low and to the far left is evidence of a lazy right-hand drive sign off and while the quality of materials was excellent, every S5 we tested fitted with the optional Bang and Olufsen 3D stereo system suffered from rattling door speakers.

Compared to the original, the crooks stole $35m worth of gold versus $4m, it ran for 111 minutes as opposed to 99, it grossed far more at the box office and many, many more bloody doors were blown off. It was an objectively superior exercise in virtually every regard. Yet the magic had gone, and the same accusation can be levelled at the judiciously effective S5. Despite that, Audi is unflinchingly confident that S5 buyers don’t believe in magic.

It may well be right.

1

SPECS

Model: Audi S5 Engine: 2995cc V6 dohc 24v turbo Max power: 260kW @ 5400-6400rpm Max torque: 500Nm @ 1370-4500rpm Transmission: 8-speed automatic Weight: 1690kg 0-100km/h: 4.7sec Economy: 7.5L/100km (claimed) Price: $105,800 On sale: Now