Powered by
  • WheelsWheels
  • 4X4 Australia4X4 Australia
  • Street MachineStreet Machine
  • Trade Unique CarsTrade Unique Cars

Seven seater comparison review: Nissan Pathfinder ST AWD

By Nathan Ponchard, 10 Nov 2016 Comparisons

Seven seater comparison review: Nissan Pathfinder ST AWD

Opportunity knocked, but Nissan didn’t fully open the door. We find the Nissan Pathfinder, while smooth and likeable, falls short of the competition.

First published in the October 2016 issue of Wheels magazine, Australia's best car mag since 1953.

Opportunity knocked, but Nissan didn’t fully open the door. 

Can’t wait to see the final score? Jump to the verdict now.

LAST time we tested (and slammed) the Pathfinder, Nissan had a conniption. ‘Surely it can’t be that bad’ went the general line of questioning, but the ST-L Hybrid was indeed an undisputed dunce. So kudos to Nissan for stumping up a base ST for this Megatest, knowing full well its US-made SUV was never going to be the darling of the group. More the plain-Jane, uncoordinated sister.

Yet there’s something about the base Pathy that cuts through its layers of mediocrity to make it almost likeable. For all the Nissan Pathfinder’s flaws, in comparison to Holden’s odious Captiva, it actually  feels plush, refined and inviting.

2016-Nissan -Pathfinder -driving -sideIn fact, smoothness is something the Nissan excels at. From its generously padded front seats to its seamless CVT transmission and a proven V6 engine that continues its winning form, the Pathfinder is surprisingly effective as a mile-eater and family carry-all. Quick too, if you’re willing to nudge its gear lever into ‘L’ (for ‘Low’) and watch its tacho soar towards 6900rpm. Holden’s similarly powerful, yet lighter Captiva might out-rev the Pathy, but it hasn’t a hope in hell of matching the Nissan’s 4.9sec PB for 80-120km/h (5.2sec in Drive), or its real-world driveability. And practicality.

A clever ‘EZ Flex’ seating system allows the second row to effortlessly tilt and slide forward, even with an ISOFIX (not top-tether) baby seat in place, and it remembers its position when slid back. It’s hard to beat for rear-row access, making a quick pull-over and iPad snatch from a misbehaving brat a parenting breeze. Pity the set-up is still configured for left-hand drive, where flipping a single outboard centre seat means exiting onto the street.

2016-Nissan -Pathfinder -rear -sideIt’s the quality of the Pathfinder’s rear seating, however, that fails to realise the promise of its plush front chairs and seat-folding brilliance. All the legroom and theatre-style vision in the world can’t compensate for dead-flat cushions with minimal under-thigh support. And while we’re throwing shade at the Pathy’s interior, its dashboard is a confusing mess of unnecessary buttons and infuriating Bluetooth operation, little of which will improve in next year’s update (see sidebar).

The Pathfinder ST is never going to be a driver’s car, with anaesthetised, yet kickback-prone steering unable to deliver any connection either side of straight ahead, though its all-wheel-drive system channels its syrupy grunt with conviction, and good-quality Continental tyres go a long way towards compensating for its soggy chassis.

2016-Nissan -Pathfinder -interiorIndeed, on country back roads, the Pathfinder is more soothing than the fidgety Captiva and Kluger, to the point where its suspension sogginess isn’t such an issue. But if you start to explore the envelope of its roadholding, the Nissan’s over-zealous ESC system gets all preachy and tries to keep a lid on any enthusiasm, acting like a Band Aid flag-waver for its lack of development polish. There’s a capable chassis underneath the Pathfinder, waiting to be realised, and in combination with better steering, sharper styling and other tweaks, it could be transformed.

But in aiming to satisfy Middle America, rather than aiming to challenge the class-best, not to mention premium-brand SUVs – as is the case with the Kia Sorento and Mazda CX-9 – the monocoque-bodied Pathfinder continues to feel like an opportunity missed.

2016-Nissan -Pathfinder -interiorNew face pending

NISSAN’S updated Pathfinder – due here in the first half of 2017 – should address many of the problems of this fourth-generation model, starting with the steering. An 11-percent-quicker rack and “improved cornering feel” will combine with an extensively revised suspension tune (firmer spring and damper rates, new rebound springs in the front struts) to hopefully lessen the vague sogginess that makes the current monocoque Pathfinder feel like it still has a separate chassis. Fresh front styling gives the MY17 model a much sharper look, and it’ll also boast up-to-date driver-assistance and multimedia tech. But the confusing, button-heavy control layout will remain unchanged.

Nissan Pathfinder ST AWD review SPECS
Price as tested: $45,490
Engine: 3498cc V6 (60°), dohc, 24v
Power: 190kW @ 6400rpm
Torque: 325Nm @ 4400rpm
Transmission: CVT automatic
Dimensions (L/W/H/W-B): 5008/1960/1768/2900mm
Weight: 1985kg
Cargo capacity: 1354 litres (to ceiling)
Tyres: Continental Cross Contact 235/65R18 106T
Test fuel cons: 13.6L/100km
0-100km/h: 8.0sec
0-400m: 15.8sec @ 148.1km/h
80-120km/h: 5.2sec
3yr resale: 52%
Plus: Quality tyres; ease of entry/egress; strong drivetrain
Minus: Vague steering; messy dash; flat rear seats
Verdict: 5.5/10

Other seven seater options

Holden Captiva LT AWDHolden Captiva LT AWD
The Holden Captiva LT AWD fails to make a captivating argument for why you’d bother over other, more composed competitors.

Honda Odyssey VTiHonda Odyssey VTi
An odyssey is an ‘epic journey’. Unfortunately for the Japanese carmaker, the story of the Honda Odyssey has been one of a downward slide.

Toyota Kluger GX AWDToyota Kluger GX AWD
The Toyota Kluger offends no one by sticking to the middle of the road. There’s no escaping that the Toyota offers plenty for the money.

Hyundai Santa Fe 30Hyundai Santa Fe 30
The Hyundai Santa Fe better at pleasing its driver, rather than shifting a tribe of seven, as we uncover headroom and visibility issues in the third row.

Volkswagen MultivanVolkswagen Multivan
The Volkswagen Multivan is certainly the leader of the space race, if not quite the final frontier. Commercial vehicle origins let it down against more sophisticated competition.