Opinion: Electric Racing is Inevitable

Like it or not, electric race series are here to stay.

opinion audi e tron formula e

It wasn’t so long ago that the idea of electric racing cars was ridiculous. All spark and no bark. About as much appeal as silent movies.

Funny thing is, electric vehicles are at the cutting edge of automotive technology, yet battery-powered cars are the contemporaries of the original voiceless films. In the very late 1890s and dawn of the 20th century, battery-electric propulsion vied with internal-combustion engines for supremacy.

The fastest, cleanest and most reliable early automobiles were electrically driven. The first car to exceed 100km/h was an electric racer in 1899. On the road and in competition, petrol power took over in the early 1900s because of the range and output limits of lead acid batteries, and the widespread availability of cheap fuel from oil.

Movies with dialogue became the norm in the 1930s, but battery technology didn’t improve sufficiently until environmental concerns forced car manufacturers to develop viable electric cars in the early 2000s. Motorsport didn’t embrace battery assistance until early this decade in F1 and then the FIA jumped on electric racing with Formula E.

Since 2014, the world’s first dedicated electric racing championship has grown remarkably, gaining the attention of an increasing number of major manufacturers. Formula E is yet to yield any return on the hundreds of millions of dollars invested in its establishment, but it has broken barriers and given ‘green’ racing a toehold. It has infiltrated the centres or inner urban areas of metropolises like Paris, Berlin, Hong Kong, Montreal, New York City and – briefly – London, staging street race events in iconic locations that F1 has long coveted.

Formula E has been accepted by some of the world’s great cities because it doesn’t create an appreciable noise. What turns off diehard enthusiasts is exactly what attracts mega-city officials.

A standard chassis and control-spec mechanicals limit costs to around $10 million a season for a two-car team, a low level of investment that appeals to car makers eager to promote their burgeoning electric car ranges. The racing among the mainly F1 refugee drivers – or ones that went close to getting to F1 – has been mostly close and action-packed, thanks largely to the narrow confines of the tight street circuits.

Across three seasons so far, crowds at the events have been decent rather than packed out, attracted by mostly promotional giveaway tickets, the festival atmosphere and easily accessible locations. Tellingly, though, the attendees have mainly been casual turn-ups rather than traditional racing fans.

That is both good and bad. The series is attracting a new generation of tech-savvy followers who have no interest in traditional racing. Dedicated followers have resisted Formula E because of the lack of aural excitement. The cars buzz and chatter, with most of the noise coming from the mechanicals and tyres, as opposed to whizzing and whirring like amplified slot cars.

They’re quickish, despite strict control of power output, and look futuristic with their semi-enveloping open-wheeler bodywork. Amid drivers having to regulate the power drain of the batteries, another quirk is the artifice of fan-voted ‘push-to-pass’ power boosts. The major bugbear for enthusiasts is that competitors have to swap cars during the races because the battery pack charge can’t last anywhere near the moderate distance of the races. That will change for the 2018-19 season, when a new long-lasting battery system will be introduced with an all-new chassis.

Formula E has just started its fourth season with factory backed Audi, Citroen, Jaguar, Mahindra and Nissan teams. BMW will officially join in 2018/19, followed by Porsche and Mercedes-Benz in 2019/20. Next year’s season will also see the introduction of a one-make support series for Jaguar’s I-Pace electric SUV.

Electric racing will boom, attracting more manufacturers as BEVs become more important, and inevitably contract when too many are involved and costs spiral. As has been the way in conventional motor sport forever.

Formula E is a part of the future of racing, but it is not the future. F1, Supercars, IndyCars and other major series will adapt, retaining – or readopting – loud combustion engines as they evolve into entertainment spectaculars more than manufacturer-funded technological or marketing showcases. Or they will if they want to survive as major sports.  


How are you finding our new site design? Tell us in the comments below or send us your thoughts at feedback@whichcar.com.au.


Subscribe to Motor magazine

Subscribe to MOTOR and save up to 49%
The world's most thrilling performance car magazine. Delivered to your door each month.



Mark Fogarty

We recommend


Tiago Monteiro Honda Civic Type R WTCC

Motorsport’s greatest tales of recovering from injury

These stories are proof that there’s more to being a motorsport professional than simple skill

15 hours ago
Cameron Kirby
Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.