Top 10 best family sedans

By David Bonnici, 19 Oct 2016 Car Advice

Mid-size sedan comparison

We tested 10 of the biggest sellers in Australian sedans to see which is the best of the current crop.

The rise of the SUV may have impacted the sedan’s dominance but the traditional family car isn’t dead yet. With new technology, spacious interiors and more economical engines, the family sedan still offers a sweet package for anyone who wants to combine practicality with a superior driving experience. With the two-horse race between Ford and Holden consigned to memory, Wheels gathered the 10 biggest sellers and put them through their paces to see which was king of the road. 

1. VOLKSWAGEN PASSAT 132TSI COMFORTLINE     

Deserves to be the benchmark of its segment.

Plus: Smooth; quick; efficient; composed; comfortable
Minus: Not quite as dynamically polished as it could be

Volkswagen Passat

The accomplished Passat ticks most boxes including excellent efficiency, smooth performance and a classy interior that makes it a pleasure to drive. Its 1.8-litre, four-cylinder, turbo-petrol and seven-speed dual-clutch combo makes for easy and effortless motoring. Passengers are looked after with air-conditioning controls and vents in the back and while rear headroom isn’t the best in class, the cabin is a pleasant place to be.

Verdict: 8.5/10

2. FORD MONDEO TITANIUM ECOBOOST     

With Falcon production now a memory, it’s finally time for the underrated Mondeo to shine.

Plus: Refinement; dynamic fluency; practicality; value
Minus: Thirst; rattles; messy instruments

Ford Mondeo

Buyers who would have traditionally flocked to the home-grown Ford Falcon will be pleasantly surprised by the Mondeo’s handling, space and polish even if the dashboard isn’t the most intuitive. The 177kW 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo provides decent grunt while effortless cornering and taut body control are enough to appease the staunchest rear-wheel-drive advocate.  

Verdict: 8.0/10

3. HOLDEN COMMODORE SV6 BLACK   

The old-school Aussie favourite still has a place in today’s market with plenty of space, comfort and obliging performance.

Plus: Excellent seats; strong performance; handling
Minus: Knobbly ride; thrashy V6; relative thirst

Holden Commodore

One of the roomiest sedans with a rear middle seat that accommodates more than a child or armrest, the Holden Commodore is only beaten for legroom by the Skoda Superb. It’s a good looking car inside and out and comes with plenty for the circa-$40k price. It shows its age under the bonnet with a big V6 that sucks more than 11L/100kms without the aid of a turbo, though it’s a pretty faithful servant when you put the foot down.

Verdict: 7.5/10

4. SKODA SUPERB      

The big Czech saloon could ably fill the Aussie-sedan void if better tuned to Australian conditions.

Plus: Value; grunt with efficiency; styling; space
Minus: Uncontrolled ride; lack of traction; stingy front seats

Skoda Superb

It was bold of Skoda to call its big sedan the Superb, but you can’t really accuse the Czech company of irony as it’s quite a good car that should gain a higher profile here once the Commodore starts arriving by ship. Interior space is more Statesman-like than Commodore, yet its 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo drinks just 8L/100kms, which is about seven schooners less than the Commodore SV6. It’s a smooth operator on urban roads but its soft suspension leaves it wanting out of town.

Verdict: 7.0/10

5. KIA OPTIMA GT      

A good-looking, features packed all-rounder that’s let down a little by a lack of handling finesse.

Plus: Slick cabin; performance; equipment; excellent tyres
Minus: Dynamics and ‘Drive Mode’ calibration still need work

Kia Optima

Even those yet to be convinced that Korean cars are actually pretty good can’t help be impressed by the equipment levels in the $46,000 Optima including the leather seats, dazzling but intuitive dashboard, heated steering wheel and cornering headlights. It’s roomy and feels relaxing to drive and sticks to the road well in all conditions but while it provides a nice smooth ride on well paved roads, it does lack composure in rougher conditions.

Verdict: 7.0/10

6. PEUGEOT 508 ACTIVE     

The conservative lines of this reliable mid-sized French sedan have improved with age.

Plus: All-round ability; chassis balance; economy; value
Minus: Firm urban ride; flair-free styling

Peugeot 508

First introduced in 2014, this isn’t as flashy as some of its competitors, yet its clean lines and unpretentious interior give it a timeless appeal. That said there are enough features to please and it’s unique enough to stand out at the lights. Its narrow body means a tight fit for three people in the back seat, but on the plus side it handles nicely and its economical 1.6-litre four-pot turbo engine pulls it along well.

Verdict: 6.5/10

7. MAZDA 6 GT   

Not the pick of the Mazda 6 range, but still a good looker with great passenger comfort.

Plus: Smooth-road handling; slick interior quality; driver appeal
Minus: Gearbox calibration; pattery ride; road rumble

Mazda 6

While it’s surprising to see the Mazda 6 this far down a list, the 2.5-litre, four-cylinder petrol engine sedan doesn’t tick as many boxes as the turbo diesel wagon – but we’ll save that one for another comparison. While it’s one of the older designs here, it’s still a good looker with a quality interior that’s particularly comfortable for back-seat passengers. The 6-speed auto doesn’t always shift when it should on windy roads, though this can be overcome by using the paddles that for a more engaging drive.

Verdict: 6.0/10

8. HYUNDAI SONATA PREMIUM      

Great value and comfort is let down by unsophisticated handling on wet and rough roads.

Plus: Solid; swift; spacious; sensible; generously equipped
Minus: Unruly wet-road behaviour; busy ride    

Hyundai Sonata

The Sonata has conservative looks that neither offend nor impress leaving its best sales pitch to the well-equipped and spacious interior and a host of features seen in cars priced beyond the Luxury Car Tax threshold. The 180kW/350Nm 2.0-litre turbo four provides more than enough grunt and while handling is great on smooth city roads it’s a bit of a mess on rougher surfaces that’s not helped by the choice of stock tyres.

Verdict: 6.0/10

9. SUBARU LIBERTY 2.5I PREMIUM       

A good value car that lacks all the charm of previous models. 

Plus: Price and equipment; grip and handling poise
Minus: Lack of charisma; dull steering; irritating ride

Subaru Liberty

There was a time when a Subaru Liberty offered something different to other sedans, but while it still has AWD as a point of difference, the latest model is let down by sausage factory aesthetics, dull steering and a 2.5-litre boxer engine that doesn’t seem at all interested. The interior looks good and is put together well, though you sit on the firm leather seats rather than in them. The sub-$40k price tag represents good value when you take into account Subaru’s good build quality, equipment and reliability.

Verdict: 5.5/10

10. TOYOTA CAMRY ATARA SL HYBRID   

The hybrid price tag is difficult to swallow with a budget interior that only a taxi driver could love.

Plus: Keen and refined drivetrain; competent chassis
Minus: Budget interior; laggy CVT; comprehensively outclassed

Toyota Camry

This Aussie-built Camry has great underpinnings, but almost everything sitting above this variant is outclassed by the rest of the cars on this list. The mid-$40k price-tag might be easier to justify if the batteries helped significantly improve fuel economy, but the 9.1L/100kms consumption was hardly class leading – though to be fair it’s very thrifty in town. It does feel nice to drive, though, thanks to the muscular petrol-electric drivetrain and effective suspension tune.

Verdict5.0/10